Source: Fraser Institute
Michael Zwaagstra and Paige MacPherson of the Fraser Institute are trying to talk Alberta out of a comforting habit. On the latest PISA results the province still leads the country in reading and science and sits second in math, behind only Quebec, and it remains well above the OECD average. Those rankings are real. They also hide how far the underlying scores have fallen.
Alberta’s PISA math score is down 60 points since 2003. Reading is down 34 points since 2009. The test treats about 20 points as roughly a grade level, so today’s students are performing about three grades lower in math than the 2003 cohort and more than a grade and a half lower in reading than students in 2009. Even the recent window is ugly. From 2018 to 2025, math dropped 25 points and reading dropped 33, and the decline has been steepest over the last decade.
Other provinces and most OECD countries have been sliding too, which is how Alberta can lose that much ground and still look good in a league table. That comparison should not be the standard parents accept. If everyone else is falling faster, finishing first does not mean students know more than they used to. It just means the competition got worse.
Zwaagstra and MacPherson point to the same problems that keep turning up in this debate: phones and screens, discovery math, balanced literacy instead of phonics, and curricula that drifted away from knowledge. Alberta has already started walking some of that back, and they argue there is still obvious work left, including stronger standardized testing so the gaps are hard to miss, curriculum guides that put core skills and knowledge first, and more room for parents to choose a school that actually teaches those things.
The rankings will keep generating easy headlines for as long as other systems decline. The scores themselves are what tell you whether Alberta students can do the work. Those scores have been getting worse for years, and treating a high rank as the whole story makes it easier to leave that slide alone.