Pipelines Keep Getting Safer While Moving More Oil and Gas

Image placeholder

The Fraser Institute points to a record that pipeline opponents rarely mention. Between 2014 and 2024, reportable safety events on Canadian oil and gas pipelines fell from 113 to 63, a drop of 42 percent, even as the volume of product moved rose by 37 percent. Measured per million barrels transported, incidents declined by nearly 60 percent. Releases of product, once the large majority of those events, now account for about one in five.

That is not a claim that pipelines never fail. It is evidence that the existing system has become safer while doing more work. The economic stakes are not small. The sector generated more than $218 billion in activity and supported over 520,000 direct and indirect jobs in 2025. Canada still sends about 91 percent of its crude exports to the United States. Line 5 alone supplies more than half of Ontario’s crude and two-thirds of Quebec’s. New capacity from Alberta to the coast and toward Ontario is, among other things, a way to reduce that single-market dependence and the disruption risk that comes with it.

Opposition to new lines often proceeds as if the alternative is that the oil and gas stay in the ground. In practice, the alternatives are rail, trucks, and a thinner set of export options. None of those options is risk-free either. Judging pipelines by a standard of zero incidents is a way of ruling them out in advance. A more honest test is whether they move large volumes more safely over time, and whether the country benefits from having more than one way to get its energy to market.

The Fraser Institute’s conclusion is modest and hard to dodge. Pipelines are not environmentally costless, and they should be held to high standards. They are also a mode of transport whose safety record has improved while throughput has grown. Blocking new capacity on the theory that the technology is uniquely dangerous sits poorly beside the actual incident numbers. Canada can argue about where lines should go. It should stop pretending the existing record shows they cannot be built safely.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!