When Judges Stop Punishing Criminals, Society Pays the Price

Image placeholder

Christine Van Geyn, Ryan Alford, and Mark Mancini have written a must-read for anyone wondering why Canada’s streets feel less safe. Their piece in Inside Policy traces how Canadian judges have increasingly turned away from meaningful punishment, favouring rehabilitation, leniency, and abstract notions of “social justice” over the basic duty to protect the public.

This shift reflects a deeper cultural change in the legal world, one that treats crime as a symptom of society’s failures rather than the choices of individuals who choose to harm others. Victims live with trauma, communities feel the fear, and repeat offenders cycle through the system while law-abiding Canadians wonder why the rules seem to protect the guilty more than the innocent.

The pattern is clear: when accountability fades, public confidence collapses. People stop believing the law works for them. We see it in rising crime rates, revolving-door bail, and a growing sense that the system has lost its way.

Canada needs judges who understand that justice includes real consequences. Protecting society isn’t cruelty — it’s the foundation of a civilized country. The authors make a powerful case for restoring balance. The era of soft-on-crime leniency has gone on long enough. It’s time to put victims and public safety first.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!