Source: Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms
The Alberta Court of King’s Bench has quashed the University of Lethbridge’s decision to cancel a February 2023 lecture by Dr. Frances Widdowson. Justice C.D. Simard found the university’s reasoning fundamentally and fatally flawed because it never seriously considered the Charter right to freedom of expression. The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms funded the case, brought by Widdowson and a student, Mr. Pickle, who had wanted to attend.
The university had booked the event, then folded after faculty, students, alumni and members of the public demanded that it not happen. President Mike Mahon cited potential harm to people on campus. In court the school tried to describe the cancellation as a mere facilities decision, as if pulling a speaker were the same thing as saying a room was already taken. The judge did not accept that. He found the university was knowingly regulating student expression on campus, which is a governmental act and therefore bound by the Charter. The right at issue belonged not only to the speaker. It also belonged to Pickle, who had a section 2(b) interest in sitting in the room and hearing the talk.
Because the original date is more than three years gone, the court did not order Lethbridge to restage the lecture. Costs are still to be sorted out. The holding is the part that travels. A public university in Alberta cannot hide a veto behind the booking office, and it cannot treat activist discomfort as a substitute for a Charter analysis. John Carpay put it in the obvious way: universities exist to host argument, including argument some people on campus find offensive. If a speaker can be removed because a faction demands it, the institution has already decided which ideas are allowed in.
Widdowson had already lost her job at Mount Royal University in late 2021. The Lethbridge cancellation was a second attempt to keep her off a campus stage. The court has now said that attempt was unlawful. Whether other administrations read the judgment before the next protest email arrives is a different question. They have less room now to pretend they were only managing a calendar.