Source: Canadian Constitution Foundation
The Canadian Constitution Foundation has closed a short, ugly file involving Corbin Chivers, a Langley realtor, and the BC Financial Services Authority. In June the regulator sent him a caution letter over two Instagram posts about Indigenous land claims and the decision to close Joffre Lakes Provincial Park to non-Indigenous visitors. The letter called the comments polarizing, inflammatory and discriminatory, and warned that they could bring the real estate industry into disrepute.
That is a professional regulator treating political speech on a public controversy as if it were a licensing problem. Chivers was not accused of misleading a buyer or breaking a transaction rule. He was told, in writing, that his views on a park and on land claims were the sort of thing that could stain the whole trade.
On September 9, CCF lawyers Josh Dehaas and Alexander Surgenor wrote the authority and said the caution letter violated his Charter right to expression. They asked that it come off his file. The regulator withdrew it this week and confirmed it will not sit on his record. Chivers called that an enormous relief and said he hoped other people in the industry would take it as a reason to keep talking about public issues.
Christine Van Geyn put the wider point the way it should be put. Professional regulators do not get to run a side business in political censorship. Canadians do not hand in section 2(b) when they get a licence to sell houses, practise law, or work in any other gated occupation. If a post is unrelated to the actual work of the profession, the regulator’s job is to stay out of it.
This one ended quickly because a lawyer showed up. Most people in licensed jobs will not get that letter written for them, and a lot of them will read the original caution and decide the safer move is silence. That is how these files do their damage even when the regulator later folds. The withdrawal is good news for Chivers. It should also be read as a warning to every other college and authority that has started grading members on their opinions.