Fixing Asylum Policy: A Rare Chance for Parliament to Show Real Federalism and Solidarity

Image placeholder

Michael Barutciski makes a compelling case in the Globe and Mail. With asylum claims hitting record levels, the Bloc Québécois is pushing an important initiative through the House of Commons immigration committee: a fair, interprovincial responsibility-sharing scheme to distribute asylum seekers across Canada instead of letting them concentrate in a few big cities.

Quebec has borne a heavy and disproportionate burden in recent years, straining local services. Now Ontario is feeling the pressure too. The article rightly argues that this problem will not stay regional — tomorrow it could hit the Prairies or the Maritimes. A transparent distribution formula, similar to Germany’s model (which uses tax revenue and population size to assign shares automatically), offers a practical way forward. The goal is not forced relocation but smart administrative incentives that respect both migrant dignity and the generosity of host communities.

True North has long called for serious reform of Canada’s broken asylum system. This conversation about equitable sharing is a step in the right direction, but it must be paired with much stronger enforcement, faster claim processing, and actual deportations for rejected claimants. Overly generous interpretations of Charter rights for temporary residents have contributed to the current mess. Fixing this is not anti-immigrant — it is about preserving public support for a managed immigration system that works for everyone.

Parliament has a rare opportunity here to demonstrate that Canadian federalism can still function. Instead of endless partisan sniping, parties should work together on practical solutions that respect provincial realities and taxpayer limits. Canadians are watching. Real solidarity means sharing burdens fairly while restoring control and fairness to the entire asylum process.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!