Source: The Fraser Institute
A new Fraser Institute commentary highlights an easy but important fix to Canada’s equalization program. A 2009 rule change meant to control costs has instead forced the federal government to spend an extra $10.5 billion over the past seven years. The rule tied the overall growth of equalization payments roughly to nominal GDP growth, creating a built-in floor that kept payments rising even when the economic gap between richer and poorer provinces narrowed.
Equalization is supposed to help “have-not” provinces provide comparable public services without resorting to crushing tax rates. That goal is reasonable. But the current formula has become perverse. When resource prices fell and provincial fiscal capacities converged in the mid-2010s, the fixed growth rule prevented payments from naturally declining. Instead of acting as a restraint, it became an automatic escalator that padded budgets regardless of actual need.
True North has long argued that federal transfer programs must be efficient, transparent, and responsive to economic reality. This is a textbook case of good intentions producing bad results. The Carney government faces serious fiscal pressure. Reforming the formula by replacing the automatic growth floor with a hard cap — while still allowing payments to shrink when provinces become more self-sufficient — is low-hanging fruit that aligns spending with the program’s original purpose.
This is the kind of practical, non-ideological reform Canada needs more of. Removing the artificial floor would save billions in coming years without harming recipient provinces. Parliament should act quickly. Taxpayers deserve a system that responds to facts on the ground, not one that locks in ever-higher spending by design.