Few parents would argue with the idea behind Bill C-34. The Safe Social Media Act would bar children under 16 from social media, require platforms to take down child sexual abuse material and non-consensual intimate images within 24 hours, and stop AI chatbots from posing as humans or encouraging self-harm. Those are popular goals, and some of them are overdue. The trouble is everything the bill attaches to them, and how much of it Parliament is being asked to approve without seeing.
The bill would create a new Digital Safety Commission to oversee a long list of online services. Many of the details would be settled later by that commission or by cabinet: which platforms are covered, how the exemptions work and what counts as compliance. Law professor Michael Geist has counted 50 separate issues the bill leaves to be decided after it passes. The under-16 ban itself comes with a large exception: platforms the commission decides have “adequate safeguards” will not need an age limit at all. In practice, a regulator would be choosing which companies get approved access to Canadian teenagers, and the bill does not set clear standards for that decision.
Constitutional lawyer Daniel Santoro raised these concerns in a submission backed by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, filed with the Commons heritage committee. Platforms would have to file “digital safety plans” addressing risks to users’ “well-being” and “psychological harm.” Those terms are elastic enough to reach speech that is perfectly legal but upsetting to someone. Enforcing an age limit means verifying ages, which could mean handing over government ID or a face scan just to open an account, and adults would have to do it too. The bill also allows hearings to be held in private. Santoro argues the bill collides with the Charter’s protections for free expression under section 2(b) and against unreasonable search and seizure under section 8.
This is Ottawa’s second attempt. The Online Harms Act, Bill C-63, drew heavy criticism for its speech provisions and died when Parliament was prorogued in early 2025. C-34 is narrower in some ways, but it keeps the central idea of a powerful new regulator with broad, loosely defined authority over what Canadians can see and post online.
Santoro’s alternative is simpler. Most of the truly harmful content in question, including child exploitation, non-consensual intimate images, and incitement to violence or terrorism, is already illegal. Strengthen the Criminal Code where needed, use the courts to order it taken down, and keep any new regulatory powers tightly limited to those categories. Parents worried about what their kids see online deserve real tools. A commission with open-ended authority over “well-being” is not one of them, and once it exists, it will not stay limited to children.