Alberta’s new campus bill tells universities to protect debate instead of picking sides

Image placeholder

In February 2023, the University of Lethbridge cancelled a lecture by Frances Widdowson after opponents objected and administrators cited potential harm to the campus community. It took Widdowson and a student who wanted to hear her, Jonah Pickle, more than three years and a court challenge to get that decision overturned. In September, the Court of King’s Bench set it aside, finding the university had not even considered their Charter rights to speak and to listen. They won in the end, but a student should not have to sue their own university to hear a lecture.

Bill 38, introduced in the legislature last week, is meant to make sure it does not come to that again. The Advanced Education Statutes Amendment Act, 2026 would require every Alberta post-secondary institution to adopt a policy committing it to protect free expression for students, staff and invited speakers. That would put an obligation into law that most schools already claim to honour on paper. It would also require each institution to adopt an institutional neutrality policy. Universities would stop taking official positions on political, social and ideological questions that have nothing to do with their academic work. The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, which funded the Lethbridge case, has welcomed the bill.

The neutrality piece is the more important of the two. When a university issues an official statement on a contested political issue, it tells every student and professor who disagrees that the institution has already decided they are wrong. Some will speak up anyway. Many will not. The University of Chicago set out this principle in the 1960s: a university is a home for critics, not a critic itself. The idea has gained ground in recent years as more schools in the United States have stepped back from issuing statements on every news event, and Alberta would be writing it into law. The rule applies to institutions, not individuals, so professors and students remain free to say what they think.

One part deserves a close look as the bill moves through the legislature. It would let the minister review each institution’s policies and order changes, with more detail left to regulations. That makes sense as a way to enforce the law against administrators who would rather ignore it. But a minister with power over university speech policies is a tool that a future government with different priorities would also inherit. The clearer the legislation is about what those policies must protect, the less room there will be to bend them later. Overall, the bill is a sensible fix to a real problem, and the Lethbridge case shows why it is needed.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!