The Supreme Court’s Insite ruling turned judges into drug policy makers, and the effects have spread far beyond Vancouver

Image placeholder

In 2008, the federal government declined to renew the legal exemption that let Insite, the supervised injection site in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, operate outside federal drug laws. Health Minister Tony Clement’s reasoning was a policy choice: Ottawa wanted to put prevention and treatment ahead of programs that, in its view, sustained addiction. Advocacy groups lost that argument politically and took it to court. In 2011, a unanimous Supreme Court ordered the minister to grant the exemption anyway.

As Kerry Sun argues for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, the problem with the ruling is not which side of the drug policy debate it favoured. It is the test the court used. The Charter’s section 7 protects life, liberty and security of the person against laws that are “arbitrary” or “grossly disproportionate.” The court found Ottawa’s decision arbitrary because, on the trial judge’s reading of the evidence, keeping Insite open served public health better than closing it. That treats a government’s disagreement with a judge about good policy as a constitutional violation. Supporters of Insite point to studies showing fewer overdose deaths nearby, and they may be right. But weighing that evidence against other goals is what elected governments are supposed to do.

The reasoning did not stay in the Downtown Eastside. Since 2011, courts have used section 7 to strike down or question laws on prostitution, public spaces and sex offender registration. In Ontario, an appeal court let a Charter challenge to the province’s emissions targets proceed. A trial judge struck down the province’s removal of Toronto bike lanes on the grounds that it would worsen congestion, before being reversed on appeal. Most recently, according to Sun, a B.C. court struck down the criminal ban on trafficking hard drugs. In each case, the logic is the same: the government’s policy was not good enough, as judged by the court.

This matters in Alberta, which has gone further than any province in moving from harm reduction toward a recovery-focused approach to addiction. It has moved away from supervised consumption sites, expanded treatment and passed compassionate intervention legislation. Whatever one thinks of that approach, it is a choice voters can judge at the ballot box. Under the Insite precedent, those decisions could be challenged by anyone able to convince a judge that a different policy would work better.

Sun’s conclusion is that until the Supreme Court revisits Insite, governments will have to rely on appeals, and in the end on the notwithstanding clause, to protect their ability to make policy. With the court now considering whether to place new limits on that clause, the question of who decides what counts as reasonable policy, judges or elected legislators, is going to come up again soon.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!