In 1970, Venezuela ranked 13th in the world for economic freedom, and its citizens were the wealthiest in Latin America. Today it ranks dead last of 165 jurisdictions in the Fraser Institute’s Economic Freedom of the World index, and the average wage is under $3,000 a year. Matthew Mitchell and Michael LaFaive tell the story briefly: the country restricted economic freedom while the rest of the world liberalized, then doubled down under Hugo Chávez and Nicolás Maduro. Price controls emptied store shelves, inflation soared, poverty exploded and about a quarter of the population left.
The authors wrote with American politics in mind. New York has elected a mayor who campaigned on city-run grocery stores and much tighter rules for landlords, and democratic socialism has more momentum in the United States than it has had in decades. But the evidence they lay out applies just as much in Canada. The index measures 46 components across five areas: the size of government, legal systems and property rights, sound money, freedom to trade, and regulation. The top four jurisdictions are Hong Kong, Switzerland, Singapore and New Zealand, where median incomes are above $85,000.
The gap between the freest and least free economies is not small. People in the freest quarter of countries produce nearly seven times as much per person as those in the least free quarter. They live, on average, 14 years longer. Poverty in the least free quarter is about 20 times higher. More than 1,000 academic studies have used the index’s data, and most find economic freedom linked to better outcomes in health, education, growth, entrepreneurship, the environment and the status of women.
None of this means the people calling for more state control want worse outcomes. Mitchell and LaFaive make that point themselves. Everyone wants affordable housing, good health care and a cleaner environment. The disagreement is about which institutions actually deliver them. That is a useful question to put to Canadian governments too. Rent controls, price caps on groceries and ever-heavier regulation all get proposed in this country as answers to affordability. Each of them makes the economy less free, and that is the direction the data warns against.
There is a home-grown version of this lesson as well. The Fraser Institute’s separate index for North American provinces and states has generally placed Alberta at or near the top among Canadian provinces, and Alberta has long had some of the highest incomes and fastest growth in the country. Prosperity does not come from good intentions. It comes from rules that let people work, build, trade and keep what they earn. As the authors put it, freedom works.