One in three Canadian kids can’t read properly by the end of Grade 3, and most provinces aren’t getting better

Image placeholder

There is a point in elementary school, around Grade 3, when children stop learning to read and start reading to learn. Students who have not made that shift by then struggle with everything that follows, from science textbooks to word problems. A new Aristotle Foundation report finds that in many provinces, a third or more of children do not make it in time.

The provincial numbers vary, but none of them are good. In Ontario, only 62 per cent of Grade 3 students met the provincial reading standard in the most recent pre-pandemic results, which means 38 per cent did not. In British Columbia, 30 per cent of Grade 4 students missed the benchmark. In Manitoba, fewer than half of Grade 3 students, 44.9 per cent, met provincial standards in 2024. Quebec fell from 77.7 per cent to 69.3 per cent between 2019 and 2021. Across the provinces, the authors estimate that between a fifth and more than half of students cannot read at a basic level by Grade 4. They found no jurisdiction showing steady improvement, with the possible exception of Alberta.

The cause is well documented. For decades, many Canadian classrooms taught reading through “balanced literacy,” which encourages children to guess words from pictures and context rather than sounding them out. Ontario’s Human Rights Commission, in its 2022 Right to Read inquiry, found that this approach fails large numbers of children, especially those with reading disabilities. It called for systematic phonics, early screening and fast intervention, and said that with proper instruction only about 5 per cent of students should still fall below grade level. Four years later, the commission found that many educators were still barely aware of its recommendations.

Alberta is the counterexample. It introduced a phonics-based curriculum in 2021, with mandatory early screening and intervention. In Fort Vermilion, where the school division adopted phonics early, Grade 9 reading proficiency rose from 43 per cent to 86 per cent. That is a remarkable result. The one problem is that Alberta does not publish its provincial reading assessment results, so it is hard to tell whether the rest of the province is seeing the same gains. If the reforms are working, the government should release the data and show it.

The costs of illiteracy do not end at the classroom door. Among Canadian 15-year-olds, the share reading below basic proficiency rose by 22 per cent between 2022 and 2025. A child who cannot read at nine is far more likely to drop out, earn less and end up in trouble with the law, and the report notes that fixing reading after Grade 3 is far harder and more expensive than getting it right the first time. The evidence on how to teach reading is no longer seriously in dispute. What is missing in most provinces is the will to act on it. And as we noted recently, the school libraries where kids should be practising have been quietly emptied at the same time.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!