The universal health systems that outperform Canada’s all let private hospitals in

Image placeholder

Canadians are used to hearing that private hospitals would mean American-style health care. The comparison that actually matters is with countries like Switzerland, Germany, Australia and Sweden. Each has universal coverage. Each spends about what Canada spends. Each delivers shorter waits and more doctors and equipment than Canada does. And as Nadeem Esmail and Mackenzie Moir point out for the Fraser Institute, every one of them lets private for-profit companies run hospitals.

The share varies widely. About 65 per cent of Swiss hospitals are for-profit, along with 40 per cent in Australia and 39 per cent in Germany. Australia’s private hospitals perform 70 per cent of its non-emergency surgeries. None of these countries has abandoned universal care, and patients still do not pay at the door. The model also fits within the Canada Health Act, which governs how care is paid for, not who delivers it. What stands in the way in Canada is politics, not the law.

Sweden offers the clearest case study. In the 1990s, Stockholm handed St. Göran, a public hospital slated for closure, to a private operator. In 2024 it had the lowest average treatment cost of any hospital in Sweden, roughly 28 per cent below the national average. Patients waited 30 to 50 minutes less in its emergency department than at comparable hospitals. In 2025, it ranked first in Sweden’s national registry for overall hospital quality. Overcrowding there ran at a third of the national rate. Lower costs, shorter waits and better quality all came from the same hospital.

Critics argue that private hospitals would pull nurses and doctors away from the public system. It is a fair concern in a country with real staff shortages, and any reform has to account for it. But the countries above have managed it while keeping more doctors per person than Canada, not fewer. The bigger risk is the status quo. Half of Canadians recently told pollsters they had avoided seeking care because of wait times, and more than a quarter had already paid for private care themselves.

Alberta has already moved part of the way by sending more publicly funded surgeries to chartered surgical facilities. Fully private hospitals would be a larger step, but other universal systems have shown it can work. Canada keeps funding a government-run hospital monopoly while patients wait. Provinces serious about fixing access should stop treating private delivery as a threat and start treating it as the norm it already is everywhere else.

Join thousands of others who enjoy our events and content!

Our email list subscribers get all of our content sent to them, and other exclusive benefits like early access to – and discounts on! – tickets for our events.

Being on our email list will always be free - sign up today!