The Canadian Constitution Foundation’s podcast Not Reserving Judgment this week asks the question many people are asking about Bill 38: will it finally protect free speech on Alberta campuses? Hosts Josh Dehaas, Joanna Baron and Christine Van Geyn go through the bill. We covered its free expression and institutional neutrality provisions last week, after the Justice Centre welcomed it.
The bill does more than address speech. Starting in 2027-28, it would let the advanced education minister set maximum tuition for programs. For existing domestic students, increases would be capped at 2 per cent in the first year of the transition. It would also let the province set minimum standards for student codes of conduct, including fair and timely processes, transparency and privacy protections. That part has received less attention than it deserves. Students who end up in disciplinary hearings over something they said often run into vague charges and drawn-out processes. Clear minimum standards could matter as much as the neutrality rules.
The word “finally” in the episode title is fair. In 2019, Alberta required every post-secondary institution to adopt a free expression policy. Four years later, the University of Lethbridge cancelled Frances Widdowson’s lecture anyway, and it took a court ruling this fall to set that decision aside. Policies on paper did not stop it. Whether Bill 38 does any better will depend on what goes into the regulations that set the minimum requirements, and on whether the minister actually uses the power to review and correct policies that fall short.
The hosts also discuss more hopeful news from Ontario: the University of Guelph and Wilfrid Laurier University both want to open new law schools. Guelph is pitching its proposal as potentially the most innovative in the country. Few details have been released so far, but a new law school starting from scratch is a rare chance to build legal education that takes viewpoint diversity seriously from day one.
The full episode is below.